Thursday, November 29, 2012

The Liberal Media: Fact or Fiction? Part 5



A week-long look at bias in mainstream American media

Part 5: Anatomy of a Calamity
"My own party spent millions to stop me from becoming the nominee AND Obama has the support of nearly every demographic in the country? Oh, this is going to be bad. Really, really bad."
By Tyrone  L. Heppard  

   At this point, it’s pretty much clear that there is no such thing as a media bias; there’s only a small group of people with power who would like the rest of us to believe there is a bias and that it is slanted in favor of the left. But even though the people generally don't buy it, that didn't stop the Romney campaign from trying the same stagnant excuse his compatriots have been using for decades.
   Anyone who followed Romney’s struggle (and that’s truly what it was – a struggle; I believe “rolling calamity” is the term being thrown about now) leading up to him becoming the presidential nominee should’ve noticed one thing. As far as the media is concerned, not even liberals were going out of their way to paint the former governor of Massachusetts in a bad light; he did a fantastic job all by himself. Let’s take a look back shall we?
   From off-color comments like, “I enjoy firing people” and, “I’m not worried about poor people”, to calling Russia our greatest political foe in the world, liking the height of Michigan’s trees, and saying 47 percent of Americans don’t take personal responsibility for their lives, Mitt Romney had portrayed himself as the less-than-desirable GOP nominee for a while.
"I got $10,000 that says you'll never see me again if Obama wins..."
   It’s interesting to see how the republican base did everything they could to try and distance itself from Mitt Romney just to end up stuck with him anyway. After all, in Romney, we see a Mormon (weird enough already…) who had to deal with trying to show the differences between a health care plan he instituted as governor and President Obama’s (because it looks an awful lot like the one republicans are complaining about right now). 
  He had to stick up for the wealthy (because almost every American was at one of the hundreds of Occupy protests last year addressing the widening gap between the rich and the rest of us), and he had to support fighting a possible war with Israel against Iran (even after a majority of Americans said they’re sick of war and want their friends a family back; provided they weren’t killed in combat).
   To any political junkie, it’s clear that the Mitt Romney isn’t your traditional republican candidate, and even if you don’t have conservative viewpoints, you have to be impressed with the way that Romney bumbled and stumbled his way to the GOP’s nomination.
   With that being the case, most of us would agree that earlier on, the Romney campaign needed to bring their base together before they started worrying about how to unite the country. And, at first, it seemed like they found a way to do that. They decided to go to that old stand-by: the liberal media bias.
   It was actually a brilliant plan. For a “non-traditional” republican like Romney looking for the support of the party, nothing says you’re a conservative more than blaming the left when you say/do something a majority of the people (or, of your party for that matter) don’t agree with while you’re in front of a news camera.
Romney probably realized this soon after Rick Santorum dropped out of the race and, like any good republican; he tried to play up the liberal media bias angle. 
   On conservative Andrew Breitbart’s radio show in April he said, “Many in the media are inclined to do the president’s bidding. I know that’s an uphill battle we fight with the media generally, but fortunately, there are other voices… which have, in many cases, a lot more credibility.”
I totally would have used this as my official presidential photo
  What’s funny is that Pew Research Center’s Project for Excellence in Journalism’s polls show that from January 2, until April 15 – when he made those remarks – Romney’s coverage had been 39 percent positive and 34 percent negative. President Obama would have no idea what that felt like, seeing as how at that point, there wasn’t a single week where positive coverage for him outweighed the negative. How did this happen? The answer shouldn’t be that surprising. It turns out that it was due to all of the republican candidates (including Mitt Romney) bashing the president at their televised campaign stops and during all of those televised debates.
   You remember the republican debates, right?! The debates the ‘liberal’ media would hold three to four of in one week (during prime time hours). The debates with campaign stops in between where the ‘liberal’ TV news outlets would broadcast live for 15-20 minutes and air random clips from throughout the day. The debates and campaign stops that the ‘liberal’ media frequently took sound bites and talking points from; the ones they talked into the ground with pundits for hours and hours. Those debates and those press campaign stops. Plus, the whole Supreme Court-challenge-to-a-healthcare-bill thing didn’t help Barack Obama either.
   On top of that, data shows that out of all the republicans running for president, the media treated Romney the best. Go Figure! Pew Research says that Romney was treated most favorably while Santorum was treated just as bad as Obama. Newt Gingrich only got positive coverage after he won South Carolina (but that only lasted a week), and Ron Paul?
   Well, the media barely covered Ron Paul, and that might sound like liberal media bias. However, if you do some research on what Ron Paul stands for and what a traditional conservative believes in, it wouldn’t be hard to understand why politically nobody even want to acknowledge him: Ron Paul and the republican base have virtually nothing in common and some of his views were a little too extreme for even the bluest of liberals.
   With this helpful data from Pew Research we learned that the myth of a liberal media bias is a fundamental part in hiding the fact that there isn't a media bias. In addition, we’ve learned that as a conservative, it’s you’re duty to say that you’re a victim of the “leftist propaganda machine”, even if it’s treated you pretty well.
  So now that future journalists know that they are probably going to be accused of working for hippies and communists for a majority of their careers, they should remember that their job isn't just to tell us stories; it's to deliver the truth to the American people as often as possible.

Tomorrow: Part 6: Mandate of The Fourth Estate

Wednesday, November 28, 2012

What He Really Thought of Your Halloween Costume



 By Bryant Clark

This is a first in a series about insight into the heterosexual male perspective for the sake of the lady folk. This is not your typical feel good Cosmo advice so buyer beware. Don’t think of it as advice as much as helpful hints when dealing with the heterosexual male variety.

Our first order of business regards how men view female Halloween costumes. To understand how men view the costumes you first need to understand how men view Halloween itself.

Halloween is a grand opportunity to show off not just your body but also your personality (no bullshit). Men want to see your tits, this is true, but what you choose to dress as will speak volumes to the men around you. What you have to understand is that, for men, Halloween costumes are almost completely synonymous with role-playing costumes (you know...like sex). Because of this, what you choose to wear will impact the snap, almost unconscious judgements that men will make about your sexual personality.

For example, if you showed up in the bedroom dressed like a power ranger, you’re either weird, not secure enough to wear a sexy outfit, or you’re cool as hell... just not all that sexy.

If you role-play as a school girl, you might be smart and you probably like to be spanked.

If you role-play as a cheerleader, you’re probably really enthusiastic, you love to yell out things in the sack, you love attention...and you LOVE the penis.

And while we’re at it... don’t be a cat. On Halloween, a guy sees cat ears and thinks BORING or at the very best generic. The costume that is too safe shows lack of commitment and lack of confidence.

Also, a word to the wise- don’t be too specific. On Halloween, a man’s easiest conversation starter is talking about your costume. If you’re some hot character from some obscure comic book or something, not knowing the reference will make us feel stupid. Men hate feeling stupid.

All in all you want to play to your strengths. Choose a costume that fits part of your personality. If you can, develop a character to pretend to be all night; or at least until you get too drunk to pretend anymore. That’s super sexy.

Again, we assume it means you can role-play not just in costume, but acting in character as well. Honestly, what could be better? But don’t over think it. Don a tight white dress with red lip stick and call yourself Marilyn Monroe; guys will eat that shit up.

To review: sexy baby? Not sexy. Sexy cop? Super sexy. You get the idea....

The Liberal Media: Fact or Fiction? Part 4




A week-long look at bias in mainstream American media

Part 4: "Manufacturing Consent"   
by Tyrone L. Heppard 

   According to conservatives, the media bias stems from the liberal attitudes of the journalists and reporters who write the news. That would mean that the power structure flows from the bottom up, and the presidents and CEOs have no responsibility for the content of the news it provides people.  
   This line of thinking is ridiculous for two reasons. Number one, the major TV news outlets are owned and operated by some of the most powerful multi-nationals in the world. To say companies like Disney and General Electric have the bulk of their power concentrated at the bottom rather than at the top is highly unlikely. Like it or not, the television news industry is a business, and any business attempting to run things in this fashion would fail almost instantly.
It's a sick sad world we live in when Mickey Mouse is a corporate overlord
   Also, just like most successful businesses, TV news outlets are run by conservatives. This is what’s expected from Fox News, but CNN, ABC, CBS and even MSNBC are all run by conservatives; people who are on the same page as William Krystal, Michelle Malkin, Charles Krauthammer, Ann Coulter and Frank Luntz. All of these folks are very opinionated, very famous and, of course, very conservative.
   Now, “The Myth the Liberal Media” is a documentary released in 1998 and it’s based off of a theory posed by MIT’s Noam Chomsky and Edward Herman from the Wharton School of Business.  Justin Lewis of the University of Massachusetts backs them up as they examine the major TV news outlets and explain how and why the owners of media outlets find it necessary to keep up the illusion of a liberal media bias.
   Chomsky would agree with conservatives when they say the media elite works to promote an agenda, but it is hardly liberal. Instead, the goal is to perpetuate the myth of a liberal media so people are distracted from what those at the top of the power structure are doing while making sure the bottom line isn’t affected – just like any other business.
   We all know that the media play an important role, not just in the lives of citizens, but in the way that they influence in the democratic process. Not only does the news tell us what we should be concerned about, it tells how we should feel about these things. TV news outlets are extremely important in this process because they’re usually the primary source people use to base/back up their opinions.
Because the media has this ability to shape our opinions and influence the way we think, one of the first questions we must ask ourselves is if the information that we are receiving is coming from a neutral source. Is it a source with a varying range of opinions and viewpoints, or does it tend to promote the interests of some, while ignoring the voices of others?
   Unfortunately, it looks as if the latter is true, and according to the experts, those who say there is a definite liberal media bias do this regularly. The Herman-Chomsky theory suggests that not only is there no evidence to prove that a liberal media bias exists; but that if there is a bias, it’s blatantly coming from those on the right or those who find themselves right of center. Chomsky explains:
"No! That's a bad dog! I'm the Decider!"
   “There’s been massive research documenting the fact that the media are extraordinarily subordinated to external power. Now, when you have that power, the best technique is to ignore all of that discussion – ignore it totally – and to eliminate it by the simple device of asserting the opposite. If you assert the opposite, that eliminates mountains of evidence demonstrating that what you’re saying is false; that’s what power means.
   And the way you assert the opposite is by just saying, “The media are liberal”. Now the question we discuss is are the media too liberal or are they not too liberal. Now that we’ve narrowed the agenda to the one acceptable question, “Are the media too liberal”, let’s have a look at the way it’s argued. If you want to show that, you would look at the media product and you would try to demonstrate that it reflects a slant or distortion supporting a liberal agenda.”
   He goes on to say that once this question is the one dominating the conversation; there is no way to show a liberal media bias exists, let alone to prove a news organization is promoting one effectively. “Nobody does this; that would take a little work,” says Chomsky. “And besides if you did it, you’d immediately fall on your face because it works the other way. So what’s done is to produce a proposal which is so idiotic that you have to wonder at the cynicism of the people who are it putting forth and their contempt for the population.” Sounds a lot like Romney’s 47 percent comment, right? Don’t worry; I’ll get to that later.
 The proposal that Chomsky is referring to here is exactly what we did in Part 2; referencing the way that journalists tend to vote. Even though there is a tendency for journalists to vote democratic, it tells us nothing about who controls the media output. With that being said, whether a TV news outlet is liberal or conservative is irrelevant for two reasons.
   One, it doesn’t matter if a journalist is a democrat or a republican; they are still a part of the same institutional structure. They are parts of the whole that make up our socio-economic base known as capitalism. It doesn’t matter if the person holding the microphone voted for Mitt Romney or Barack Obama this year. If she works for CNN, her job is to boost CNN’S ratings. Period.
   Secondly, according to Herman and Chomsky, the question we really need to be asking is not how liberal (or conservative, for that matter) the media is, but does the media actually have the ability to freely express opinions from whatever source objectively?
   Chomsky and Herman would say, “No.” This is because conservatives have been propagating this idea of a liberal media bias for so long people are starting believe that what we hear from reporters is actually controlled by those reporters; not the owners and advertisers and conservative think tanks who work with them. As Lewis says in the documentary, that’s, “a bit like saying the workers on the factory floor decide what the car industry produces”.
   The experts in the documentary also talk about “filters”. By this, they mean that with so much information out there, it’s impossible to talk about all of it, so it’s up to the people putting the news together to decide what is going to be a part of the news for that day and what’s not. That’s not the problem; in fact, that’s to be expected from anyone working in the news business.
   The real problem becomes apparent when we ask that specific question: “is the media free”? We find out that in most cases it’s not, and that while conservatives swear up and down there’s a liberal tilt in the media, the real bias is coming from the people who own the media outlets and the advertising firms that do business with them. The CEOs and public relations guys are the ones making the rules; journalists are forced to play by them.

Tomorrow: Part 5: Anatomy of a Calamity

Tuesday, November 27, 2012

Attacks on U.S. Embassies Did Not Suddenly Begin Under Obama. Foreign Affairs History 101.


By John Amaruso

In the wake of the tragic events of the Benghazi attack which left 4 Americans dead, including Diplomat Christopher Stephens, questions as to the current administration's efficacy against terrorist attacks has come into question.

Media outlets such as Fox News, and independent conservative blogs all over the blogosphere are calling the incident a direct result of poor leadership under President Obama and Secretary of State Hilary Clinton. Moreover, claims of scandal and misinformation have plagued the story like bugs to a light.

Yes the details are murky, as all events during war usually are. Yes, they could have been more forthright with the information they had. Yes, Susan Rice should not have gone around peddling the same talking points if the informational basis of said talking points weren't still in their infancy.

But here's another question; is the attack on the U.S. Embassy in Libya an isolated event? Is this something that was a direct result of poor leadership, a lack of resources or attention to detail?

It may be one thing to say the information pool surrounding the events and the handling of the tragedy leave much to be desired. But to say that this occurred only because of this particular administration's poor policies would be to say that only people who have sky dived in the past 4 years suffer from an increased risk compared to it's history.

Strange analogy you may say, but let me explain. Sky diving is inherently dangerous. It is a field that is constantly being looked at in order to improve jumper safety, instructional efficiency, plane functionality etc.

An attack on the American Embassy in Beirut, 1983.
63 people died in the attack
Much like foreign missions conducted by the C.I.A. or the State Department, the danger is inherent. It is a field that is constantly being looked at in order to improve security personnel safety, protocol efficiency, effectiveness of operations employed etc. U.S. Embassies are a constant target for attacks from foreign agents who do not approve of U.S. presence in their country.

Now, if we are to look at it like that, under this administration, the amount of attacks on U.S. Embassies have actually declined. Benghazi has been the only attack on a U.S. Embassy in a country which is currently at peace with the U.S. (Afghanistan, Iraq, fall under countries 'at war').
Attack on the U.S. Embassy in
Nairobi left 223 people dead


Under Reagan's watch, 63 people died in an attack on the U.S. Embassy in Beirut in '83



Under Clinton's watch, 223 people died in coordinated attacks on the U.S. Embassies in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, and Nairobi, Kenya. Think about that to put this in perspective.



Ironically enough, in March of 2006, an almost mirror image of Benghazi happened in Karachi, Pakistan, where a U.S. Diplomat, David Foy, was specifically targeted by militants, and killed along with 4 other Embassy workers.


Here are the numbers/past attacks on U.S. Embassies since 9/11.

June 14, 2002, U.S. consulate in Karachi, Pakistan
Suicide bomber kills 12 and injures 51. 

February 20, 2003, international diplomatic compound in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
Truck bomb kills 17.

February 28, 2003, U.S. consulate in Karachi, Pakistan
Gunmen on motorcycles killed two consulate guards.

July 30, 2004, U.S. embassy in Taskkent, Uzbekistan
Suicide bomber kills two.

December 6, 2004, U.S. consulate in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia
Militants stormed and occupied perimeter wall. Five killed, 10 wounded.

Suicide Bombing outside U.S. Embassy in Karachi, killing 4, including U.S.
Diplomat David Foy
March 2, 2006, U.S. consulate in Karachi, Pakistan
Suicide car bomber killed four, including a U.S. diplomat, David Foy, directly targeted by the assailants.

September 12, 2006, U.S. embassy in Damascus, Syria
Gunmen attacked embassy with grenades, automatic weapons, and a car bomb (though second truck bomb failed to detonate). One killed and 13 wounded.

January 12, 2007, U.S. embassy in Athens, Greece
A rocket-propelled grenade was fired at the embassy building. No one was injured.

July 9, 2008, U.S. consulate in Istanbul, Turkey
Armed men attacked consulate with pistols and shotguns. Three policemen killed.

March 18, 2008, U.S. embassy in Sana'a, Yemen
Mortar attack misses embassy, hits nearby girls' school instead.

September 17, 2008, U.S. embassy in Sana'a, Yemen
Militants dressed as policemen attacked the embassy with RPGs, rifles, grenades and car bombs. Six Yemeni soldiers and seven civilians were killed. Sixteen more were injured.
 (Provided by the Daily Kos)


If these numbers don't tell you something, I'm not sure what will. It is a fact that in the past 4 years, attacks on U.S. Embassies have declined relative to our history.

To say this administration caused the attacks would be to say that only sky diving today causes death, not sky diving in the past.

Personally, I don't have any plans to go sky diving anytime soon.

The Liberal Media: Fact or Fiction? Part 3

A week-long look at bias in mainstream American media

Part 3: "Working The Ref"
"What do you mean I wrecked the economy and lied about going to war?! You're not seriously gonna call that are you? ARE YOU?!"
by Tyrone L. Heppard

   Whether the people like them or hate them, Fox News is having an impact on everyone. Ironically enough, we see the liberal bias argument coming from the right; the same people that Fox tailors its news for. In fact, Fox News actively does what it can to help spread the word about the ‘obvious’ liberal bias in the media. For example last year, Fox News anchor Sean Hannity aired a documentary called “Behind the Bias: The History of Liberal Media.” His claim is that for years, the media has been going out of their way to portray republicans, “as either evil or stupid”.
Sean Hannity talking about media bias. Pot, meet kettle.
   The problem with this theory is that in order for that to be the case, there would have to be a certain power in journalists’ hands they frankly don’t have. In addition, there’s evidence showing some people who talk about there being a media bias know that it’s just a talking point that can’t be proven. Eric Alterman, who writes for The Nation, wrote “What Media Bias?” in 2003. He opens it up with two quotes said during a 1992 interview by a man named Rich Bond while he served as the chair of Republican Party:


   Rich Bond, then chair of the Republican Party, complained during the 1992 election, "I think we know who the media want to win this election – and I don't think it's George Bush." The very same Rich Bond, however, also noted during the very same election, "There is some strategy to it [bashing the 'liberal' media].... If you watch any great coach, what they try to do is “work the refs.” Maybe the ref will cut you a little slack on the next one.” 
   Alterman continues to give examples of top conservative pundits and republican leaders who “kid” about the liberal media bias and how it was, “often used as an excuse by conservatives for conservative failures." In other words, not only does the right admit that that liberal media bias is a bunch of malarkey, they admit to using it to justify whenever something doesn’t go their way.
   In addition, it’s clear that the mindset among conservative thinkers is to pressure the media on purpose. By calling reporters and journalists biased now, the same journalists will be less inclined to do their job when there’s actually something newsworthy or of public concern to report. Understanding this point will become crucial when we take a look at who truly holds the sway over what goes across a TV news outlet’s air waves.
   Try as I may, I was hard-pressed to find a psychologist (or a psychiatrist for that matter) who was good enough at their job yet informed enough about politics to look a the GOP's constant assertion of a bias in media that doesn't exist and to come up with a diagnosis. I failed to do so, but I think I found the next best thing.
   So it looks like I'm ending class early today; but don't worry, there will be a lot covered tomorrow - even a movie to watch! What should you expect? Here's a hint.

Tomorrow: Part 4: "Manufacturing Consent" 

Monday, November 26, 2012

The Day Socialism Came to America- The 2008 Election

By Kenny Brown





Whatever happened to this great country? What has happened to the land of the free and the home of the brave? When did we sell out our capitalist values for Russian style socialism?

I will tell you when. It was the day in 2008 that we elected Barack Hussein Obama as our President. Before that day this country never allowed the government to fund and control medical programs and health care. We never let taxpayer dollars go to bailout companies. We never had any socialized programs. Extreme debt and fiscal issues did not exist. We only had honest, hard working men in Washington and the White House and Barack Obama has changed all of that.

Scandals within government have arisen and that has never happened before, the deficit went up for the first time in the recorded history of the country, and people started receiving Food Stamps and welfare out of nowhere. In one moment, when all the votes were tallied on that November night in 2008, America began to drown in a sea of Socialist values and corruption. America was deflowered.

A new age of taxation began where people were lead to believe that a Government could only exist if it taxed it's citizens. We lost a lot on that day. We lost the hard work of George Bush. The magic of the Reagan years where the budget was balanced, debt never rose and scandals involving Middle Eastern countries were unheard of. And it has happened again.

The US citizens, working through Democracy, have reelected and decided to continue this Age of Socialism. We have never seen anything like this before. I just hope we can get back to the regular, debt free, civil liberty filled, constitution loving, Conservative lifestyle we all were accustomed to. Especially those years of personal responsibility and small government we saw under modern Republican leaders.


-Rush Limbaugh approved.

The Liberal Media: Fact or Fiction? Part 2



A week-long look at bias in mainstream American media

Part 2: We Got the Numbers!
by Tyrone L. Heppard  
   
   With regard to a liberal bias in American media, everyone thinks they have evidence that backs up their side. This is because surveys have been taken that “prove” and “disprove” the existence of such a bias.
   Take for instance the Media Research Center whose taglines include, “I don’t believe the liberal media” and, “America’s media watchdog”. You only need to spend 10 minutes on their official website to find out that they decry any media coverage that, ironically enough, doesn’t conform to the traditional conservative line of thought; but more on that later.
   They did, however, do some research that needs to be considered as far as liberal media bias is concerned. In the annals of the MRC archives, there’s a 1981 study conducted by Robert Lichter and Stanley Rothman (of George Washington University and Smith College, respectively) in the form of a book called “The Media Elite”.
   Lichter and Rothman set out to survey journalists and reporters to learn more about their political attitudes and voting patterns. They interviewed people who worked in either the newspaper or TV business. Among those surveyed were the NY Times, the Washington Post, the Wall Street Journal, PBS, ABC, NBC and other media outlets.
   In 1986, David H. Weaver and G. Cleveland Wilholt publish “The American Journalist” which helps back up the results of the Lichter-Rothman study. They surveyed 136 staffers and executives from the Associated Press, United Press International and the Boston Globe – who they thought represented the elite media. 32.3 percent of reporters said they rated themselves as more liberal; only 11.8 percent called themselves conservative. Also, out of all the journalists surveyed, 43 percent said they were democrats and only six percent said they were republican.
   Okay - so the reporters tend to be liberals who vote democratic. What about the audience though? They are the ones who ultimately have to decide whether they buy the argument; that because journalists tend to vote democratic, they are likely to push a liberal agenda in the media. For an answer to that question, we have to look at who Americans like to get their news from.
   Before looking at which media outlets Americans trust and distrust the most, much like the journalists, we have to look at the voting patterns of the general American public. According to the right-leaning Rasmussen Reports, polls in April 2012 showed that the 36.4 percent of Americans are republicans, 33.4 are democrats and 30.2 percent are 3rd party or independent voters.
   Earlier this year, Public Policy Polling released the results of their 3rd annual news trust polls. They asked people their opinions of many of the major TV news outlets (Fox News, MSNBC, CBS, CNN, ABC, NBC) as well as PBS and Comedy Central (due to the popularity of the Daily Show and The Colbert Report). Right away, there are some very interesting results.
So the only people who trust Fox News are the people who work there?
   With 34 percent of the vote, Fox News turned out to be the most trusted and distrusted news source for Americans; they topped both lists. Underneath Fox in the trust column, people said they trusted PBS next (17%) followed by CNN (12%) and ABC (11%). The other outlets didn’t even break double digits. Those who distrusted Fox first said they distrusted Comedy Central most after that (16%). MSNBC (15%) and CNN (11%) followed.
   As far as who people trusted based on party affiliation, democrats say they trust PBS, ABC and CBS the most (with 21%, 19% and 17%, respectively) while 53 percent of democrats said they didn’t trust Fox. Republicans all said they trusted Fox the most with 68 percent of the vote; MSNBC is their least trusted TV news source with 28 percent of the vote.The results from the polling show two important things with regard to the liberal media bias. 
   First, when compared to the results of similar polls taken in 2010 and 2011, the data shows that despite all of this talk of a liberal bias, trust in TV news has been on the rise. Second, republicans don’t seem to trust anything but Fox News, while both democrats and independents think everyone except Fox is legitimate.
   So what's their angle? Why keep harping on something that people aren't buying? I'm sure there's a simple explanation. Seriously. This won't take long....

Tomorrow: Part 3: "Working the Ref"